At a glance
ClinicalIndex Comparison RecordStandardized by ClinicalIndex from the ClinicalTrials.gov record · verify against the source.
Is There Any Indication for Protein Free Products in Patients With Advanced CKD at Risk of Malnutrition?A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial
In Brief
A clinical study evaluating LP group and NP group for Chronic Kidney Diseases and Malnutrition. Completed, enrolled 35 participants across 1 site.
Detailed Summary
It's a pilot study with an open label randomized-controlled design. Estimated number of patients should have been 38, taking in account of a maximal drop out up to 20% of the sample. We enrolled 35 patients, 27 of whom terminated the study as per protocol (14 in the Low protein (LP) group and 13 in the Normo Protein (NP) group). Patients were treated for six months with two different dietary prescriptions: 1. LP group (n=17) was prescribed high calories/low proteins diet (30 Kcal/kg and 0.6-0.7gr/kg respectively). In order to assure prescribed calorie intake, this group was supplemented with commercial protein free products (protein content \<2%). 2. NP group (n=18) was prescribed high calories/normal proteins diet (30 kcal/kg and 0.8 gr/kg respectively). The primary hypothesis of the study was that in CKD patients at risk of malnutrition (4 ≤ MIS ≥7) with a persistent spontaneous low protein and calories intake, the prescription of a LP diet was not inferior to NP diet regarding the development of malnutrition (i.e.MIS ≥ 8). We also wanted to test whether in these patients, the prescription of a LP diet was superior to the NP comparator regarding the control of the metabolic complication of chronic kidney diseases (i.e hyperphosphatemia, inflammation and metabolic acidosis), the progression on dyna/sarcopenia, inflammation and possibly on the progression of renal disease itself.
Study Details
Timeline
Interventions
LP group patients replaced pasta, bread, biscuits etc. with low protein substitutes. We allowed them to consume more animal products than NP, preferring white meat to red meat and trying to limit cold cuts as much as possible. Furthermore, they were advised to prefer fresh or frozen fish, instead of dried or smoked one as well as to prefer fresh cheeses to seasoned ones. As for legumes, we advised to combine them with bread or normal cereals, for protein complementarity.
NP group was given the indication to try to eat the second dish only once a day or to split the portion of the second plate between lunch and dinner, if they wanted to keep the habit of making the meal complete. It was also given the indication to prefer, among protein sources, those of plant origin. We also indicated to alternate or replace cow's milk with plant substitutes such as: rice, almonds' or oats' drinks. Furthermore, we suggested to prefer white meat and to avoid offal and processed meat. Moreover, we indicated to substitute dried or smoked fish with fresh or frozen one.